Introduction
The death of a parent can be an emotional and difficult time, particularly where disputes arise over the distribution of their estate.
For some families, those difficulties are compounded when a child discovers that they have been excluded from a parent's Will or have received substantially less than their siblings.
While parents in Ireland generally have the freedom to decide how their estates should be distributed, that freedom is not absolute.
Under Section 117 of the Succession Act 1965, a child may be entitled to bring a claim against a deceased parent's estate where the parent has failed in their moral duty to make proper provision for them.
However, not every disappointed beneficiary will have grounds to bring a successful claim.
In this article, we answer some of the questions most commonly asked by clients about Section 117 claims.
What is a Section 117 Claim?
Section 117 of the Succession Act 1965 allows a child to apply to court where they believe that a deceased parent has failed in their moral duty to make proper provision for them, having regard to the parent's financial circumstances.
If the court is satisfied that the parent failed in that duty, it may order that provision be made for the child from the estate.
Importantly, a Section 117 claim does not necessarily involve challenging the validity of the Will itself.
Instead, the court is asked to consider whether the deceased parent made proper provision for the child, either through their Will or during their lifetime.
Section 117 applies where a parent dies leaving a Will. Different rules apply where a parent dies without making a valid Will.
Can an Adult Child Bring a Claim?
Yes.
One of the common misconceptions about Section 117 is that it only protects young children or children who were financially dependent on their parents.
In fact, adult children can also bring claims under Section 117, including those who are financially independent.
However, the fact that an adult child has received little or nothing from a parent's estate does not automatically mean that a claim will succeed.
The court must consider whether the deceased parent failed in their moral duty to make proper provision for that particular child.
This involves examining the individual circumstances of the family and the estate.
What Factors will the Court Consider?
There is no automatic entitlement to an equal share of a parent's estate.
When considering a Section 117 claim, the court will examine the circumstances from the perspective of a prudent and just parent.
Relevant factors may include the:
Size and Value of the Estate: The value of the assets available for distribution and the deceased parent's overall financial circumstances.
Child's Financial Circumstances: Whether the child has particular financial needs or difficulties.
Child's Health: Whether illness, disability or other circumstances create additional financial needs.
Provision Made During the Parent's Lifetime: Whether the parent previously provided financial assistance, property or other significant benefits.
Circumstances of Other Children: The competing needs and circumstances of siblings.
Relationship between Parent and Child: Including any relevant history of estrangement or family difficulties.
No single factor will necessarily determine the outcome.
Each claim must be assessed on its own facts, and the court has discretion in deciding whether any additional provision should be made.
Does a Parent Have to Leave Their Estate Equally Between Their Children?
No.
Irish law does not generally require parents to divide their estates equally between their children.
A parent may have legitimate reasons for leaving different amounts to different children.
For example, one child may have received substantial financial assistance during the parent's lifetime, while another may have greater financial needs.
Similarly, a parent may decide to leave a particular property or business to one child.
The question under Section 117 is not simply whether the Will is fair or whether each child has received an equal share.
Rather, the court must determine whether the parent failed in their moral duty to make proper provision for the child bringing the claim.
An unequal distribution of an estate does not, by itself, establish grounds for a successful Section 117 claim.
Is There a Time Limit for Bringing a Section 117 Claim?
Yes, and this is one of the most important aspects of these claims.
A Section 117 application must be brought within six months from the date on which representation is first taken out in respect of the deceased parent's estate.
This will generally be the date of the first Grant of Probate or Letters of Administration.
Crucially, the time limit does not run from the date of death or from the date on which a child discovers that they have been excluded from the Will.
The six-month deadline is strict, and the court does not have a general discretion to extend it.
Given the strict six-month deadline, it is important to seek legal advice as soon as possible if you believe you may have grounds for a Section 117 claim.
Can a Section 117 Dispute Be Resolved Without Going to Court?
Not every inheritance dispute needs to result in a contested court hearing.
Depending on the circumstances, it may be possible to resolve a Section 117 dispute through negotiations or mediation.
However, engaging in negotiations or mediation does not stop the six-month statutory time limit from running. Where necessary, proceedings must be issued within that period to protect the child's position.
An early assessment of the legal merits of a claim can help the parties understand their respective positions and explore whether a practical resolution can be reached.
Where necessary, proceedings must be issued within the applicable time limit to protect the child's position.
How Lavelle Partners Can Help
Our Litigation & Dispute Resolution Team advise clients on contentious probate matters, including claims under Section 117 of the Succession Act 1965.
We act for clients considering claims against a deceased parent's estate and for executors and beneficiaries responding to such claims.
We understand that inheritance disputes can involve sensitive family relationships and significant financial concerns.
Our approach is to assess the merits of each case at an early stage, provide clear advice on the available options and, where appropriate, seek to resolve disputes without unnecessary litigation.
Where court proceedings are required, we represent clients throughout the litigation process.
Further Information
If you have been excluded from a parent's Will, are concerned that proper provision has not been made for you, or are dealing with a Section 117 claim against an estate, please contact Ciarán Leavy, Partner and Head of our award-winning Litigation & Dispute Resolution Team.
:format(auto))
)
:format(auto))
:format(auto))
:format(auto))
:format(auto))